An article in the July 21 online edition of Nature magazine posed researchers the question, "Would it be a good thing if all mosquitoes were eradicated from the earth?" I've often been posed a similar question in slightly different form, namely, "What good are mosquitoes (or ticks, or chiggers)?"
Aside from the purely speculative question that Nature asked (we couldn't get rid of all the mosquitoes in the world in a thousand years if we tried), perhaps a more realistic question would be, "If we could get rid of even one mosquito species, should we?"
Humans have been sadly effective in causing the extinction of species from the dodo bird to innumerable beetles and butterflies and other creatures. Most of the time it is accidental, or through neglect. Habitat destruction is probably the number one cause of species elimination.
Now, through the power of biotechnology it may be possible to cause the deliberate extinction of certain species. So, if we had the power, should we do it? There are powerful arguments on both sides. Some scientists have argued that if we could destroy all the species of Anopheles and Aedes mosquitoes, for example, the world would be a better place and millions of lives would be saved.
As the writer in Nature points out, there are many species which appear to be pests to us humans, but which hold together important strands in the web of life. We humans have never been very good at predicting what would happen when you pull one of those threads. Eliminating all species of no-see-um flies (a family known for its painful bite and transmission of certain viruses, protozoa and filarial worms), for example, would include elimination of a species of these flies that pollinate the cacao tree. As the Nature article threateningly proposes, "Imagine a world without chocolate!"
I am still unsure that we should deliberately cause the extinction of all mosquitoes. And I suspect I'm not alone in feeling this way about insects. I wonder what PMPs would say if someone come up with a practical proposal to cause the extinction of German cockroaches? I'll bet there are more cockroach lovers out there than anyone realizes.